• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer

Under Fire: The Blitz Diaries of a Volunteer Ambulance Driver

  • Amazon
  • Bluesky
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Threads
  • YouTube
Naomi Clifford

Naomi Clifford

Books + Talks

  • Books
  • Talks
  • About
  • Contact
  • Blog

Horace Cotton: The extraordinary Ordinary of Newgate

22 November 2016Naomi Clifford

During the research for my book Unfortunate Wretches one name kept coming up: The Reverend Horace (sometimes Horatio) Salusbury Cotton, the Ordinary (chaplain) of Newgate from 1814 to 1837. There are conflicting opinions of this man. Some described him as “humane”, others saw him as insensitive and slimy with a ghoulish enjoyment of his responsibility for giving convicted felons the news on whether they had been reprieved or would hang.


Horace Salusbury Cotton was born in about 1774, the son of Robert Salusbury Cotton of Reigate. At the age of 17 he matriculated at Wadham College, Oxford, and graduated four years later. By 1800 he was the vicar at Desborough in Northamptonshire1 and by 1805 curate and schoolmaster at Cuckfield Grammar School in West Sussex. By the time he had moved to Hornsey in 1810 he was married to Caroline Amelia Merriman (1803) and had started a family.2

Newgate Chapel, from Microcosm of London; or, London in miniature
The Condemned Service at Newgate Chapel, by Thomas Rowlandson, from Microcosm of London; or, London in miniature

On 29 July 1814 the Court of Aldermen in the City of London appointed Cotton Ordinary (resident Chaplain) of Newgate Prison, replacing the Rev Dr Forde, who had shown such a disinclination to engage with the pastoral responsibilities of his job that he was forced to resign. This was a time of growing disquiet at the appalling suffering produced by the overcrowding, dirt, disease and destitution in Newgate and at the moral degeneration of the inmates. Perhaps the Aldermen felt that the religious fervour of Horace Cotton would improve things.

Within nine months of his appointment, Cotton was called to give detailed evidence about his duties as Ordinary of Newgate to the Committee on the King’s Bench, Fleet and Marshalsea Prisons. His answers to the MP Henry Grey Bennet reveal much about his job. He described his routine: visiting the sick, instructing prisoners in their moral duties and administering religious consolation. He gave two services every Sunday and organised a school for boys aged under 15. Tellingly, he felt the prisoners revered him: ‘I always treat them [the prisoners] as reasonable beings; I always take off my hat when I go into the ward, and while I treat them thus, they will treat me with respect.’ Bennet asked him if he kept a journal. ‘No,’ he said. This was a lie. Cotton kept a personal diary, quite apart from his official one, listing all the executed prisoners he encountered in Newgate, and against each name he wrote notes on their crime and their demeanours. Three sketches are included, probably done by a prisoner, each showing Cotton in action in the gaol. The notebook came to light in 2012 during a house sale. The BBC ran a feature on it (video).3

Cotton has been described as a ‘fire and brimstone’ preacher4 and certainly his treatment of the condemned could not be described as in any way ‘nuanced’. He preferred a sledgehammer approach. In his Hangmen of England Horace Bleackley describes Cotton as a ‘robust, rosy, well-fed, unctuous individual, whose … condemned sermons were more terrific than any of his predecessors’.5

Eliza Fenning, a young cook-maid condemned to death in 1815 for the attempted murder of her employer and his family, was deeply distressed by Cotton’s address during the condemned sermon. A friend of her alleged victims, Cotton had chosen Romans 6: ‘What fruit had ye then in those things whereof ye are now ashamed? For the end of those things is death.’ He alluded directly to her, saying that she had been persuaded by Satan that revenge was sweet and that he would protect her, but had then abandoned her. Fenning was almost certainly innocent.

Cotton’s treatment in 1824 of the banker Henry Fauntleroy, who was convicted of a monumental financial deception, attracted more serious censure. He felt it appropriate to take his text from Corinthians: ‘Let him that thinketh that he standeth take heed lest he fall.’ Perhaps he did not see the irony of the text for a man about to endure the New Drop within hours. After Fauntleroy’s death, the Aldermen decided that the public were no longer to be admitted to the condemned service6 and reminded Cotton that his job was to console convicted felons, not to harass or distress them in their remaining time on earth.

Horace Cotton, Ordinary of Newgate, Announcing the Death Warrant, by W. Thomson (c 1826).
Dr Cotton, Ordinary of Newgate, Announcing the Death Warrant, by W. Thomson (c 1826). Courtesy tate.org.uk via London Street Views

Cotton took a callous, almost sadistic relish in his role with condemned prisoners. The prisoner artist W. Thomson’s portrayal of him announcing the Report (the death warrant) to a convicted felon, standing fully upright, his hand raised, conveys this. This coldness is also seen in the terse conclusions about executed prisoners he recorded in his secret execution diary. Of John Ashton, convicted of highway robbery in 1814, he wrote: ‘This man sprung up on the scaffold after he was turned off [dropped] and distinctly cried out “Am I not Lord Wellington”! He was pushed off again by the Executioner.’

There were rumours that Cotton was venal. The Freethinkers (atheists) who were imprisoned for blasphemy in Newgate were his implacable enemies and in the pages of their journal, The Newgate Monthly Magazine, alleged that Cotton intervened directly in justice. According to William Haley in a detailed account, a prisoner named Boniface managed to persuade Cotton to help his cause by telling him that he was due to come into the sum of £300 from his father but could not get access to it. ‘Out of pure Christian charity,’ wrote Haley, ‘our old parson provided him with counsel, who by some legal quirk, got rid of the capital part of the charge, and the worthy burglar was only found guilty of the minor charge.’ Haley, who had regular and close contact with Cotton, described him as ‘panting for gain’ and alleged that he conspired with the Recorder, Newman Knollys, ‘that infamous, tyrannical villain’, to bring about a sentence of 14 days. Boniface’s promises were empty and when he realised he would not be paid Cotton quite illegally arranged to have Boniface detained in Newgate beyond his sentence.7

Most prisoners had no money to buy their way out, and Cotton does not appear to have profited particularly from his position. His living was comfortable, earning him £400 a year and free accommodation at a time when a male servant might make £16-20.8

According The Morning Post, when he died in Reigate in 1846 at the age of 72, he left ‘few worldly goods’.9

With thanks for pointers in Cotton’s story to Baldwin Hamey of London Street Views.

diagram of childbirth (cross-section), 1821.

“Is she or isn’t she?” How an age-old plea of pregnancy saved women from execution

Women and the Gallows review: Ripperologist

Beatrice Parvin on Women and the Gallows

My guest blog for Geri Walton: Women on trial for infanticide

Basic Instincts: The art of Joseph Highmore at the Foundling Museum

1814: Murder or manslaughter? The trial of Mary Ann Adlam

Horace Cotton: The extraordinary Ordinary of Newgate

Three women hanged for poisoning their husbands in 1836: Sophia Edney

Three women hanged for poisoning their husbands in 1836: Betty Rowland

Recipe for rice pudding (19th century)

Three women hanged for poisoning their husbands in 1836: Harriet Tarver

black and white etching (?) of an 18th century in a mob cap.

The bloody career of Maria Theresa Phipoe

Monochrome (sepia) photograph of the writer George Eliot - middle-aged Victorian woman with bad teeth, hair centre parted

The confession of Mary Voce, who inspired George Eliot

Gangs of Market Drayton: Ann Harris (1828)

Charlotte Newman and Mary Ann James

The end of Frances Thompson, a dealer in false banknotes

The Coffee Grinder Bernard de Hoog (1867–1943) McLean Museum and Art Gallery

Susannah Holroyd: Serial killer

Ann Hurle’s story: The execution of “a young woman of education”

The birth of the pound note and the fate of Sarah Bailey

The hazards of hiring: Melinda Mapson

‘Frenzied despair’: Sarah Pugh murders her daughter

Ann Mead: The life and death of a nursemaid

Pregnant and condemned: Pleading the belly and the jury of matrons

William Hone on the case against Elizabeth Miller, who mistook arsenic for oatmeal

The Norfolk Murders, Part 2: Catherine Frarey and Frances Billing

The Norfolk Murders, Part 1: Mary Wright

Sarah Chandler: The one that got away (1814)

Ann Baker, hanged for stealing sheep (1801)

Mary Thorpe: First woman to be executed in the 19th century

Mary Morgan: “A Provincial Tragedy” (1805)

1802: Maria Davis and Charlotte Bobbett, who dropped a baby on Brandon Hill, Bristol

Ann Heytrey: hanged at Warwick for murdering her mistress

Charlotte Long, hanged in 1833, for setting fire to haystacks

Hannah Palmer: Executed with her brother for the murder of his wife (1801)

illustration of hanging outside newgate prison

Mother of 8 Ann Woodman, condemned to death for uttering forged banknotes

old print of elizabeth fry reading to prisoners in newgate

Harriet Skelton’s letter to the Bank of England

courting couple 1802

“A Warning to Thousands”: Sarah Lloyd

old print of elizabeth fry reading to prisoners in newgate

Harriet Skelton – “Chosen for death”

Child-stripping and child stealing in the Regency

47 cases of infanticide at the Old Bailey

inquest on margaret hawse

The death of Frances Colpitts – Part 2

sir richard birnie

The death of Frances Colpitts

keelmans hospital newcastle

1829: The cost of executing Jane Jameson

eliza fenning broadside detail

Eliza Fenning: Guest post at All Things Georgian

murder of mr steele from newgate calendar

1807: The execution of Holloway and Haggerty: tragedy upon tragedy

  1. Foster, J. (188-1892). Alumni Oxonienses: The Members of the University of Oxford, 1715-1886 and Alumni Oxonienses: The Members of the University of Oxford, 1500-1714. Oxford: Parker and Co.
  2. The Clergy Database
  3. Other personal diaries of Cotton’s were confiscated by the Aldermen, but this one seems to have escaped detection
  4. Gatrell, V. A. C. (1994). The Hanging Tree: Execution and the English People 1770-1868. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
  5. Bleackley, H. (1929). Hangmen of England. London: Chapman and Hall.
  6. This was later rescinded.
  7. Haley, W. (1825). Life in Newgate. The Newgate Monthly Magazines, or Calendar of Men, Things and Opinions. 1 (September 1824-August 1825). London: R. Carlile. I have not traced Boniface, but Haley’s accusations are so detailed and describe his conversations with Cotton about the case that it is difficult to disbelieve him.
  8. Sussex Advertiser,  30 Mar 1835.
  9. 1 Sep 1848.

Reader Interactions

Trackbacks

  1. Rev. Dr. Cotton, ordinary of Newgate prison | London Street Views says:
    22 December 2021 at 9:14am

    […] You can read more on the controversial approach towards the Newgate prisoners by the Rev. Cotton in Naomi Clifford’s blog post on him (here). […]

    Reply
  2. Forging Money in the Regency- the sad case of John Binstead, 1815 – Georgian and Victorian Britain says:
    31 March 2022 at 8:31pm

    […] the scrutiny of the gaol’s ‘ordinary’ (resident chaplain) Horace Cotton ( more about him here). Cotton’s task was to help the condemned man’s launch into eternity to be as respectable […]

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Footer


historical writers association logo



Useful resources

  • Image Databases
  • Maps and Gazetteers

Copyright © 2025 Naomi Clifford | Privacy policy